| Date_of_Win | Winner | Won_From | Event | Special_Comments |
| 06/07/2003 | "Superstar" Rocky Styles | "The Solution" Scott Fowler | Omega | Title win resulted in the closing of the company until 6/2007 |
| 01/25/2003 | "Superstar" Rocky Styles | Mangle | New Year's Revolution | |
| 02/17/2002 | "Superstar" Rocky Styles | n/a | Back From Beyond | Rocky stripped Big Papa of the title and gave it back to himself |
| 01/31/1999 | "Superstar" Rocky Styles | Punch Fresh | The 8th Day | Won vacant title |
| 04/05/2003 | "The Solution" Scott Fowler | Mangle | Last Man Standing | Rocky Styles was injured and sripped of the title. Fowler defeated Mangle in the finals of the LMS tourney. |
| 10/09/1999 | Big Papa | "Superstar" Rocky Styles | Beyond the Grave | |
| 02/17/2002 | Mangle | "Superstar" Rocky Styles | Back From Beyond | Mangle pinned Jon Brody in a triple threat match |